Cracked Conch Cafe came highly recommended from our charter. We had an epic fishing day and caught an array of tuna, king mackerel, and mutton snapper. Being tired, we were hoping for a restaurant that would turn our catches into an amazing dinner. They asked if we had recommendations for how we wanted them cooked and they gave us their suggestions as well. They NAILED it! Every single dish was soooo delish and the service was great! Highly recommend!

12/24/2024 you know how I feel about breakfast foods! The Cracked Conch Cafe did not disappoint! The servers greeted us and smiled when we walked in. We sat ourselves at the counter (my favorite!) and a server quickly took our drink orders. I ordered a Spanish omelette which was hot and tasty and chock-full of ingredients. Yummy! She had a BLT which was described as delightful and the toast it was served on was rich and buttery. There's a full bar too. Evidently they are known for the conch, which I did not try but they are one of few places that serve it other than a fritter. On my list to try next time. Decor and ambience aren't high on the list of my priorities. Is it a little dated? Sure. But it was clean and quiet and I appreciate that. Friendly staff and hot food made to order are the reasons I would recommend the Cracked Conch Cafe. The menu has enough variety to please everyone. Give it a try!

Listen, when you pull up into the parking lot at 7:30PM on a Friday, and you're the only car, go ahead and go in! Don't second guess whether you should, it'll be worth it. The staff are super friendly, the food was fabulous and in my opinion, and worth the fare paid. Then again, I don't mind paying for good food and service. Oh and get the Cracked Conch, you'll not be disappointed.

This is our favorite for "CONCH". Not easy to find on menus and every other restaurant has conch fritters. We like the real conch steak, strips or basket. The breakfast portion is delicious with eggs your way. Recent facelift this place is the real deal! Don't pass on this one it's been around for a long time for a good reason! Excellent service too!

Went for dinner on a Monday night. Place was almost empty and we considered leaving although reviews had been good. Glad we stayed. The restaurant looks like an old diner. The staff were friendly enough and to our surprise the food was delicious. My clam chowder and my husband's conch chowder were both very good. My fried snapper and mashed potatoes were tasty and I thoroughly enjoyed. Seems to be a popular breakfast spot but I suggest trying it for dinner too.

Love this place! Incredible omelets, best grits and biscuits!!! The conch fingers are sensational, they melt in your mouth. And such friendly service, beautiful people. I can't wait to come back to the keys and visit this establishment again